On July 2nd, 2008, members of the Fuerzas Armadas Revolucionarias de Colombia (Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia, or FARC), a leftist-guerrilla movement over four decades old, accidentally released their most prized hostage: Ingrid Betancourt. The FARC had kept her hidden in the jungles of
Now freed, Betancourt immediately became an international celebrity with videos of her rescue and reunion with her family broadcast around the world. She spent much of her first weeks of freedom providing interviews to the likes of Larry King and Ann Curry of CNN and MSNBC, respectively, describing the horrors of captivity that aged her decades. The world listened as she addressed the French Parliament, the people of
Betancourt’s rescue captures the contrast from the strong position the FARC attained less than a decade ago to their current status of a severely weakened movement. 2008 has seen several things go wrong for the FARC: hostages have been freed, high-ranking officials have died, and the international backlash towards the group seems stronger than ever. Their forty-year campaign to take over power in
II. The Origins of a Terrorist Organization
The sad truth of
The conservatives lost the presidency that they held for most of the first three decades of the 20th century when voters turned them down in 1930 during the Great Depression that severely devalued Colombia’s prime exports, notably coffee. The liberals took control for the following sixteen years with reforms that included more land rights for the poor, a freedom welcomed and quickly taken advantage of; however, two liberal candidates in the 1946 elections split the liberal vote and conservative Mariano Pérez took office. Pérez’s party, bitter at the persecution they faced from the liberals during their sixteen year reign, gained power with a sense of vengeance. La Violencia, a grueling political battle that would claim the lives of over 200,000 Colombians—often in the cruelest of ways—had commenced.[4]
Violence sparked in 1948 when Jorge Gaitán, leader of the left-wing of the liberal party and one of the presidential candidates that lost in the 1946 election, was assassinated in the capital, Bogotá. The conflict continued in the following decades that brought a fascist dictator, a military coup, and rule by a military junta. Some party leaders in 1957, in an effort to quell the violence and political unrest, started the National Front, a bipartisan coalition designed to share power equally among conservatives and liberals in virtually every office of Colombia’s government (with the presidency changing hands every four years). Unfortunately, violence and animosity did not cease, as opposition to the National Front arrived from their partnership with the
The political scene in
A simple glance at the Colombian conflict may bring comparisons to other rebellions in the
As the FARC have no inherent unified base—as opposed to the French and American revolutions as well as several others—their rebellion must gather support and victories with tactics frowned upon by the international community. Rather than welcoming flocks of people that leave home to join the FARC, the rebels must go into communities to recruit new guerillas. Among the recruits are children under eighteen years of age (who make up around 20-30% of all FARC combatants) who join out of fear, promises of money, food, and protection. The Human Rights Watch documents that the FARC train children as young as thirteen to fight and they “are often ordered to participate in summary executions, torture, murder, kidnapping and attacks on civilians,” while the lingering threat of harming the children’s family always keeps them in check.[7] The FARC also use savage fighting techniques that often leave neutral and innocent civilians dead or displaced. Though the FARC repeatedly claim that they don’t target civilians, land mines used to repel both Colombian national forces and other paramilitary groups often kill innocents. In 2006 alone, mines affected 320 Colombians, including 66 children, and killed 57 of them. Fear of encountering mine fields leads farmers and entire villages to relocate away from their homes. Defying international humanitarian law, the FARC shrugs off their critics while justifying the casualties as “the norm” in any military conflict.[8] The use of gas cylinder bombs, highly destructive devices with imprecise aim, is another FARC necessity in battle that provides more international contempt toward the rebels as the bombs destroy innocent lives and villages.[9] The mere application of these techniques—most of which are now abandoned by rebel groups around the world—prove both the determination of the FARC and their lack of a proper support base that would eliminate the requirement to use tactics that harm civilians.
The status of the Colombian conflict—political with no bearing on class—also supplies advantages to the rebels. The conservative-liberal disagreement—the very same that harbored the FARC’s creation—carries on when discussing how to react to the FARC. Politicians are at odds discussing the FARC problem: one side promotes peace negotiations and cease-fires, while others, such as the current Colombian president Alvaro Uribe, support a tough, hard-line, military policy against the FARC. Because the presidency shifts between the two ideas on a regular basis,
III. The Story of Ingrid Betancourt
By the time Ingrid Betancourt ran for President of Colombia in 2002, history’s course had changed the way the FARC looked. With the
Betancourt was not new to politics. Her mother, a former Miss
In January 2002 she took to the streets of Bogotá to acquire support for her Presidential campaign. With all the beauty that her mother had, Betancourt ran her Colombia Nueva campaign by passing out Viagra to commuters, asking them to “let their vote be like Viagra for Colombia,” implying, quite correctly, that the country was dissatisfied with their government.[14] The ironic part of Betancourt’s tale occurred on February 14, 2002, where Betancourt and the other presidential candidates, including Horatio Serpa and Alvaro Uribe, met with the FARC in a demilitarized zone for a public conference. During her allotted time to speak, Betancourt urged the FARC to work with the national government for peaceful negotiations. She would also utter a line that would be repeated by millions of people around the world in the following decade: “No más secuestros.” No more kidnapping.
Nine days later, on route to a campaign stop into a former demilitarized zone, Ingrid Betancourt and her campaign manager, Clara Rojas, were taken by guerrilla forces into FARC custody. One of her kidnappers, Nolberto Uni, would later report in prison that the kidnapping was “never planned,” and that “the order was to detain all politicians of national stature.”[15] While the event entered the headlines of international news stations, Colombian’s could only keep living life and go on with the elections: the kidnapping of politicians was not at all unusual, and many felt she paid for her risk-taking as she was warned of the dangers of traveling by ground. The soon to be lame duck president was powerless to do anything even if he wished it. Betancourt’s family even discouraged any rescue attempts as they feared for her life if a confrontation occurred.
The result of the Presidential Election on May 26th, 2002 proved Betancourt’s claim of dissatisfaction with the government. The majority of the voters chose Independent candidate Alvaro Uribe, whose campaign was centered on a tough policy against the FARC that included military build up and foreign aid. Uribe’s election predicted that Betancourt’s residence with the FARC would last as long as he held power. While some of the FARC’s kidnappings are aimed at gaining ransom money, others attempt to pressure the government to engage in prisoner-exchange deals with them. Because of Uribe’s firm stance of not negotiating with the terrorist organization, a deal between his administration and the rebels proved unlikely. On the other side, since Uribe’s administration crippled the FARC’s military power, prisoner exchanges became all too important for the rebels. Eventually Betancourt’s family, including her first husband and two children in
After over six years of silence, a few times interrupted by photos, videos, and letters that proved that Betancourt was alive, the liberation that caught the world by storm occurred on July 2nd, 2008. In a rescue mission dubbed Operation Check that Colombian authorities called “an unprecedented operation that will go down in history for its audacity and effectiveness,” Colombian militiamen, adorned with t-shirts containing the image of Che Guevara, pretended to be a non-governmental humanitarian group that offered the FARC a helicopter to transfer fifteen hostages (including Betancourt) to another FARC hideout.[17] The mission would not be possible without the help of one particular guerrilla who became disillusioned with the FARC and helped the Colombian government fool one of the top-ranked officials of the FARC, a man called Cesar. The FARC had lost their most valuable bargaining chip in a year that will prove to be very costly to them.
The story of Ingrid Betancourt provides clear insight into the current situation of the FARC. When she was captured in 2002, a nation was desperate for action, the FARC was affecting the governments’ every move with strong military pressure, and the national government had seemingly too many problems on their hands with every cartel and guerrilla group threatening stability. Six years and four months later, the country is strongly behind its leader, as are big international names, and the desperation that used to belong to Colombians now belongs to the guerrillas. Peace and stability now seems more attainable then ever, as Colombian dissatisfaction finally united to turn against the plagues that harmed the country for decades. Betancourt, who ran her campaign against the theory of strong military force against the FARC, thanked Uribe after the rescue and commented that he “has been a very good president.”[18] But to accomplish such a drastic and positive change in the Colombian conflict, Mr. Uribe needed and was granted help from a particular ally.
IV. The
The US-Colombia relationship got off to a terrible start when Teddy Roosevelt helped neighboring
In 1999, President Bill Clinton and Colombian President Andrés Pastrana created Plan
The consequences from an influx of
The liberation of Betancourt secured another large success for both the US and Colombia as three of Betancourt’s companions were American citizens taken hostage when their military spy plane crashed in FARC territory in 2003. According to the White House, “the
President Bush has already commenced advertising for a stronger relationship. On July 22nd, he celebrated Colombian Independence Day at the White House with a speech on
With or without free trade between the two nations, the
Whatever the arguments on whether American dollars need to be in
V. The Future FARC Policy
On July 20, 2008, Colombian Independence Day, hundreds of thousands of Colombians took to the streets clad in symbolic white while crying for peace and the release of remaining hostages. Ingrid Betancourt’s speech at a rally in
The goal of peace is near, but the government must change some aspects of policy while continuing others to achieve a peace with a minimal amount of blood spilt. Peace negotiations have failed in the past, but previous attempts were not backed up by the strong position that the government now attains. Alfonso Cano, identified as the leader of the FARC after Manuel Marulanda’s death, stated in a 2001 interview with The Economist that “our struggle is to do away with the state as now it exists in
The greatest mistake the Colombian government can make is one of arrogance: the fact that the FARC can be militarily defeated may tempt officials to sponsor a full-on attack on the FARC. Such a rash action would precipitate mass casualties from both sides and potentially harm the several hundred hostages still awaiting freedom in the jungles. Afterwards, even with the probable outcome of a victory, international support for
For the first time in modern history,
[1] “
[2] “Quick Guide: Colombian Conflict.” BBC News, www.bbc.co.uk, 3 November 2006.
[3] The modern Colombian government describes the 1860s and 1870s as the “Epoch of Civil Wars.” 51 out of the 240 months contained “some form of civil conflict.” “
[4] “La Violencia, dictatorship, and democratic restoration." Encyclopædia Britannica. 2008. Encyclopædia Britannica Online. 04 Aug. 2008 <http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/126016/Colombia>.
[5] Ibid
[6] “Peace for
[7] Women make up around 30% of all FARC combatants. “
[8] “Report Cites Rebel’s Wide Use of Mines in
[9] “
[10] “Peace for
[11] “
[12] The Kidnapping of Ingrid Betancourt. Women Make Movies. Prod. Victoria Bruce and Karen Hayes. 2003.
[13] Betancourt claims that while Congress was investigating links between Samper and a Colombian cartel, she was ambushed by a group in her vehicle and barely managed to escape thanks to her skillful driver. Ibid. Samper was President between 1994-1998, and the investigation proved inconclusive.
[14] Ibid.
[15] Uni sent a letter of apology to French President Nicolas Sarkozy (Betancourt, via her first marriage, has French citizenship) while serving a 34 year long imprisonment for abduction. See “Betancourt’s kidnapper says he’s sorry.”
[16] “Fresh Plea for Colombian Hostage.” BBC News. www.bbc.co.uk. August 17th, 2008.
[17] “How
[18] “‘Miracle’ rescue frees Betancourt, three Americans.” Bajak, Frank.
[19] “The Drug War’s Southern Front:
[20] “Helping
[21] The FARC was officially annexed on November 2, 2001. See “Comprehensive List of Terrorists and Groups Identified Under Executive Order 13224.” US Department of State. www.state.gov.
[22] “
[23] “Peace for
[24] The killing of Raul Reyes in
[25] “President Bush Honors Colombian Independence Day.” President Bush. The White House. www.whitehouse.gov. July 22, 2008.
[26] “Press Briefing by Dana Perino.” The White House. www.whitehouse.gov. July 3rd, 2008. In a suspicious coincidence, Republican Presidential candidate John McCain was visiting
[27] “DNC blasts McCain on
[28] “How dare the Colombians rescue Ingrid Betancourt?” The Economist. www.economist.com. July 3rd, 2008.
[29] “Chavez calls for Russian alliance.” BBC News. www.bbc.co.uk. July 22, 2008.
[30] “Peace for
[31] “End Farc ‘hate’, Betancourt urges.” BBC News. www.bbc.co.uk. July 8th, 2008.
[32] “Chavez urges FARC to end struggle.” CNN News. www.cnn.com. June 8th, 2008.
[33] “Freeing Ingrid Betancourt.” New York Times. www.nytimes.com. July 4th, 2008.